Sourdough French Toast

Made with crusty sourdough bread, this sourdough French toast is complete with crispy edges and a fluffy center just the way French toast should be. Grilled to perfection and topped with butter, maple syrup, and fresh berries, this recipe is perfect for a special occasion or a hearty weekend breakfast.

If you’ve never made French toast with sourdough bread, I highly suggest you give it a try. While brioche, challah, and Pullman loaf are most often recommended, using sourdough bread is a fun French toast variation that adds an additional element of flavor, while providing a fluffy interior and crispy edges. Not to mention, sourdough is the most real food form of bread, so it keeps the extra healthy too.

Prefer to watch the video?

[adthrive-in-post-video-player video-id=”NfJI43Bp” upload-date=”2023-03-15T19:57:23.000Z” name=”Sourdough French Toast” description=”Crusty sourdough bread soaked in an egg, milk, and vanilla batter and grilled to perfection to create the best sourdough French toast recipe!” player-type=”collapse” override-embed=”false”]

Can you make French toast with sourdough bread?

Yes, you can absolutely use sourdough bread to make French toast. The sturdy nature of sourdough bread makes it a great option for French toast, as it’s less likely to fall apart when cooking, similar to that stale bread, which is often used to make French toast. Plus, the natural tanginess of sourdough bread adds a welcomed complexity of flavor to the otherwise sweet French toast.

Honestly, if you love sourdough bread, you’re going to love this sourdough French toast recipe.

What You’ll Need

Here are the ingredients you’ll need to make sourdough French toast:

• Sourdough Bread: As you may have guessed, sourdough bread is the star of this sourdough French toast recipe. Feel free to use fresh or stale sourdough bread, both work well.
• Eggs: One of the essential components of the custard base for French toast, and they add a little protein too.
• Milk: The second essential component of the custard base for French toast, I recommend using whole milk or 2%, as skim milk won’t provide the same richness. While I think milk works best, you can also use heavy cream or half-and-half.
• Vanilla Extract: To add some flavor.
• Cinnamon: To add some warmth.
• Sugar: To add a touch of sweetness.
• Salt: To season the egg mixture.
• Butter: To ensure the French toast is golden brown and add a touch of richness.

Once you’ve got the base recipe down, the topping options are endless, I’ve shared a few ideas below.

How to Make Sourdough French Toast

Making sourdough French toast is as simple as making regular French toast, you just use sourdough bread instead! Here’s how you’ll make it:

1. Make the custard. In a medium mixing bowl, combine the custard ingredients; eggs, milk, vanilla extract, sugar, and cinnamon, and whisk until well combined.
2. Soak the sourdough. Slice the bread and then transfer the slices of sourdough, one at a time, into the bowl of custard and allow to soak for a couple of minutes until well coated.
3. Warm the pan. While the sourdough is soaking in the custard mixture, melt some butter in a large pan on medium-high heat.
4. Pan-fry the bread. Once the sourdough has soaked and the pan is hot, transfer the slice of soaked sourdough to the pan and grill for a few minutes on both sides until golden brown.
5. Keep it warm. Once the slice is toasted, transfer it to the oven to keep warm and continue working in batches until all the slices of bread are grilled into French toast.

Once all of the slices are cooked, you can serve the French toast immediately or store leftovers in the fridge or freezer.

Tips for the Best Sourdough French Toast

Start with good bread. If you’re using sourdough bread, you’ll have this covered. However, for the best results, ensure that you are using authentic sourdough. Unfortunately, there is a lot of fake sourdough bread on the market so it’s to know what to look for so that you are buying and using real sourdough bread.

Don’t cut your bread too thin or thick. The ideal thickness for a slice of French toast is 3/4″ to 1″ thick. Slicing your bread too thin can result in overly soggy bread while slicing it too thick can leave the center dry and uncooked. For the best results, buy or use an unsliced loaf and cut the slices yourself.

Nail the egg-to-milk ratio. Eggs and milk are essential ingredients to the custard used to cook French toast, however, if you get the ratio off, you’ll end up with an overly eggy or wet dish. A general rule of thumb is to use one egg for every 1/4 cup of milk.

Use whole milk. While technically any percentage of dairy will work, whole milk will provide the best texture and flavor. Not to mention, it’s a nutrient-dense and well-balanced food complete with equal parts carbohydrates, protein, and fats.

Season your batter. While milk and eggs are the essential custard ingredients including vanilla and cinnamon enhance the flavor, sugar adds just the right amount of sweetness, and a pinch of salt can help to balance everything out.

Don’t under-soak the bread. It’s important to allow your sourdough to soak long enough in the custard mixture. Taking it out too quickly will result in a dry center. Instead, you want to ensure the liquid penetrates the bread for a soft, custardy center.

Don’t skip the butter. For the best results, cook your sourdough French toast in butter. While some people will suggest cooking it in oil, cooking French toast in butter adds an additional nutty flavor and richness to the dish.

Best Toppings for Sourdough French Toast

To be honest, there are SO many different toppings you can add to French toast with sourdough bread. Here are some of my personal favorites.

• Maple syrup
• Honey
• Brown sugar
• Powdered sugar
• Jam
• Peanut butter
• Almond butter
• Nutella, or hazelnut spread
• Fresh berries
• Sauteed apples
• Sauteed peaches

What to Serve with Sourdough French Toast

Given sourdough bread French toast is primarily a source of carbohydrates with healthy fats and moderate levels of protein, if you want to make it a more well-balanced breakfast, I would suggest serving it with an additional source of protein and fiber. Some ideas include:

• Scrambled eggs + Blueberries
• Breakfast sausage + Peaches
• Bacon + Banana
• Greek yogurt + Raspberries
• Cottage cheese + Strawberries

More French Toast Recipes:

• Apple Cinnamon French Toast

Print